If you would like to make a comment, please fill out the form below.
Catherine
I’ve actually never met a doctor who DIDN’T promote healthy eating and living over patchwork medicine. Since there are doctors in my family (and dinner parties), I’ve met a fair number. I think that some of the hostility and confusion from both doctors and the general public is because of the term “natural medicine”. Eating a well balanced diet is one thing, but paying piles of money to hire a naturopath to give you little vials of chammomile and other herbs and spices with no science behind them . . . well, that’s a very different matter. If we can make a clear distinction between natural medicine and naturopathy, there will probably be fewer disputes.
Patchwork medicine, great phrase, I’ve never heard that one before. I agree with you about the snake oil. The problem is getting objective science for unpatentable products — you can’t patent nature.
It’s an excellent point about natural medicine vs naturopathy. I don’t know anything about naturopathy, I’m just pro giving the body what it needs :-)
I read yesterday that doctors will now be prescribing omega-3 to heart attack survivors to prevent further attacks. I once went on a Cardiac Rehab course for the gym where I worked — we got a lot of rehab referrals at the gym.
This is great of course, but don’t we need more resources at the other end? — prevention?
sphygmo
He consciously selects research that supports his products, which causes me to be highly suspicious of his motives. He is a businessman first, and a caregiver second, and is (if not worse) the same as the “depraved” institutions he is going against. His usual line is, all products are dangerous except for mine. Though the articles he cited might in themselves be true, his careful selection/omission does not make him a trustworthy source. There are many other non-profit organizations with unbiased information, and if one is looking to know what their options are, Mercola’s site is NOT the best on the internet. My opinion has always been: if he’s selling something, you can’t trust him to be unbiased.
I’ve been aware of Dr. Mercola for a while and I have to say that what you say certainly isn’t my experience.
His products, in my view are carefully and ethically chosen.. stuff like krill oil, save the planet type light bulbs, pans that don’t off gas, that sort of stuff.
I’ve never seen any evidence of him adjusting his theories to suit his bank balance.
He’s a clever guy for sure–you have to be to achieve that level of success–and a hard worker too.
For me, he get massive amounts of brownie points for speaking the truth about the medical model–it’s strengths and severe weaknesses.
Do you have any specifics you’d like to share which would back-up your accusations?
Cheers
Mike
marianne sites
SIMPLY PUT, making something a business is not at the bottom of something being bad, since it is SELFISHNESS that is destructive, not true UNABUSED ‘SELF RELIANCE’, the latter being PRODUCTIVE when the ONE bottom-line remedy to ALL correctness is applied: The Golden Rule, better put, Righteous Dominion, remedially put: No Abuse Of Power! If we really want to teach our children to grow up recognizing what not to become or enable, THIS IS IT(!):…That they should NOT become ENABLers of the selfish, because it is US, the spineless enablers who allow abuses of power, position, opportunity, time, ourselves and others…it is US. An *abuser simply cannot be successful without the allowance of the *enablers; the enablers keep it going, the enablers, provide the money, the enablers trust the devious, because the enablers are often either cultured to trust those who would gradually harm, often because those who would harm are trained by some THEY trust, like medical school who have much traing material written by the prescription companies themselves. It would be wise of us all to remember that it’s not everyone else’s job to lift the battle ax for us, nor is it everyone else’s job to research for us..we need to lift a finger……because there are no little things!
marianne sites
…wanted to add..KUDOS to Dr. Mercula, and he deserves to become a trillionaire, but honestly, I don’t think it’s money that’s where he gets his motivation OR satisfaction,… he’s the kind that could lose everything and be a happy camper….because he knows what to do with the things available to him for his well-being, whether or not a bank account should be available. Money’s only a ‘coupon system’, I think Mercola’s show wise dominion over his sense of trade on behalf of the needs or others. He doesn’t personally know me yet I know he cares about me, so he’s doing something right, when I try his approach and I’m actually helped instead of harmed. :) Marianne Sites
I have followed Dr. Mercola since the start and agree with Marianne that he could lose everything and still be happy. I think he truly believes in the products he sells. He speaks his mind freely and for years he barely pushed any products at all. I did buy one product (the krill oil) and am glad I did. And if you do use the non stick pans I suggest you stop using them. Don’t buy his if you don’t want but he’s right that the non stick pans (he would like you to replace) are doing damage.
I think it takes a brave person (a doctor no less) to get the truth out there. You don’t have to buy his products but his newsletters don’t cost a dime yet have some of the best information i can find out there. i love Mercola and will read him for a long time to come.
I’ve actually never met a doctor who DIDN’T promote healthy eating and living over patchwork medicine. Since there are doctors in my family (and dinner parties), I’ve met a fair number. I think that some of the hostility and confusion from both doctors and the general public is because of the term “natural medicine”. Eating a well balanced diet is one thing, but paying piles of money to hire a naturopath to give you little vials of chammomile and other herbs and spices with no science behind them . . . well, that’s a very different matter. If we can make a clear distinction between natural medicine and naturopathy, there will probably be fewer disputes.
Hi Catherine,
Patchwork medicine, great phrase, I’ve never heard that one before. I agree with you about the snake oil. The problem is getting objective science for unpatentable products — you can’t patent nature.
It’s an excellent point about natural medicine vs naturopathy. I don’t know anything about naturopathy, I’m just pro giving the body what it needs :-)
I read yesterday that doctors will now be prescribing omega-3 to heart attack survivors to prevent further attacks. I once went on a Cardiac Rehab course for the gym where I worked — we got a lot of rehab referrals at the gym.
This is great of course, but don’t we need more resources at the other end? — prevention?
He consciously selects research that supports his products, which causes me to be highly suspicious of his motives. He is a businessman first, and a caregiver second, and is (if not worse) the same as the “depraved” institutions he is going against. His usual line is, all products are dangerous except for mine. Though the articles he cited might in themselves be true, his careful selection/omission does not make him a trustworthy source. There are many other non-profit organizations with unbiased information, and if one is looking to know what their options are, Mercola’s site is NOT the best on the internet. My opinion has always been: if he’s selling something, you can’t trust him to be unbiased.
Hi Sphygmo
I’ve been aware of Dr. Mercola for a while and I have to say that what you say certainly isn’t my experience.
His products, in my view are carefully and ethically chosen.. stuff like krill oil, save the planet type light bulbs, pans that don’t off gas, that sort of stuff.
I’ve never seen any evidence of him adjusting his theories to suit his bank balance.
He’s a clever guy for sure–you have to be to achieve that level of success–and a hard worker too.
For me, he get massive amounts of brownie points for speaking the truth about the medical model–it’s strengths and severe weaknesses.
Do you have any specifics you’d like to share which would back-up your accusations?
Cheers
Mike
SIMPLY PUT, making something a business is not at the bottom of something being bad, since it is SELFISHNESS that is destructive, not true UNABUSED ‘SELF RELIANCE’, the latter being PRODUCTIVE when the ONE bottom-line remedy to ALL correctness is applied: The Golden Rule, better put, Righteous Dominion, remedially put: No Abuse Of Power! If we really want to teach our children to grow up recognizing what not to become or enable, THIS IS IT(!):…That they should NOT become ENABLers of the selfish, because it is US, the spineless enablers who allow abuses of power, position, opportunity, time, ourselves and others…it is US. An *abuser simply cannot be successful without the allowance of the *enablers; the enablers keep it going, the enablers, provide the money, the enablers trust the devious, because the enablers are often either cultured to trust those who would gradually harm, often because those who would harm are trained by some THEY trust, like medical school who have much traing material written by the prescription companies themselves. It would be wise of us all to remember that it’s not everyone else’s job to lift the battle ax for us, nor is it everyone else’s job to research for us..we need to lift a finger……because there are no little things!
…wanted to add..KUDOS to Dr. Mercula, and he deserves to become a trillionaire, but honestly, I don’t think it’s money that’s where he gets his motivation OR satisfaction,… he’s the kind that could lose everything and be a happy camper….because he knows what to do with the things available to him for his well-being, whether or not a bank account should be available. Money’s only a ‘coupon system’, I think Mercola’s show wise dominion over his sense of trade on behalf of the needs or others. He doesn’t personally know me yet I know he cares about me, so he’s doing something right, when I try his approach and I’m actually helped instead of harmed. :) Marianne Sites
I have followed Dr. Mercola since the start and agree with Marianne that he could lose everything and still be happy. I think he truly believes in the products he sells. He speaks his mind freely and for years he barely pushed any products at all. I did buy one product (the krill oil) and am glad I did. And if you do use the non stick pans I suggest you stop using them. Don’t buy his if you don’t want but he’s right that the non stick pans (he would like you to replace) are doing damage.
I think it takes a brave person (a doctor no less) to get the truth out there. You don’t have to buy his products but his newsletters don’t cost a dime yet have some of the best information i can find out there. i love Mercola and will read him for a long time to come.
Erin